?

Log in

Intelligent Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion [entries|friends|calendar]
Sensible discussion on Fullmetal Alchemist

[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ calendar | livejournal calendar ]

pronouns [02 Mar 2007|10:26pm]

blueshimmer
[ mood | curious ]

Since Japanese has so many ways of saying "I" depending on your personality and to some degree your gender, I'm curious to know how various characters refer to themselves, both in the anime and in the manga, but particularly in the manga, since I can't verify that stuff for myself, being completely illiterate where kanji/kana/hirogana are concerned.

I know that Edward refers to himself by the assertive "ore" and that Alphonse uses "boku"
I'm pretty sure I heard Winry use the feminine "atashi" and I heard Mustang say "ore"

I can only assume that Envy uses the gender-neutral "watashi" if he's supposed to be as ambiguous as he is, but I haven't paid too close of attention to his speech patterns, partly because he changes so much. Greed, I'm pretty sure, uses "ore."

What about the others? How do the various characters refer to themselves? Do most use the generic "watashi" or do a lot of the guys use "ore"?

5 Veiws Discussed

a question on pubs... [05 Jan 2007|03:24am]

grygon
We've seen Roy in a bar having drinks at least once in the anime... in central?... does any one know if the bar has a name? I don't recall seeing the outside of the building with a name above the door, but then at the time I wasn't looking for one.

If not, does it have a name by chance in the manga? I've read to vol9 but can't recall them being in a bar just yet...

I'm a stickler for details, and yes this little, itty, bitty piece of info is for a fanfic. How'd you guess?
2 Veiws Discussed

Help? [12 Sep 2006|01:07pm]

frisket17
[ mood | hopeful ]

I should first introduce myself, I'm Melissa. I run an FMA discussion/project entitle virtuoussin

That isn't too terribly important, outside giving you a little glimpse of who I am. I'm hopeful that you, the community, could possibly help me. I'm unsure if anyone knows what a MUSH, MUCK, MUD, MU* is, so I shall give a small crash course:

A MU* in general is an online game where as you need a client like telenet [almost all computers have this] or more commonly, a downloaded client like SimpleMU which is free. You're then able to plug in information like a port and address and log on to a themed environment/game. I've MU* space. I'm reamping it currently to be a Full Metal Alchemist MUSH (the different names for these games usually involves differences in code and how they're run.)

Since this is a community of discussion, I figured the snags I have for the game would be best answered here. [also, if anyone is familiar with MU* systems and would like to become Staff on the game, do let me know]

The game's timeline will proceed roughly around Episode 23... However outside watching 1-23, or trying to use dialup to surf the net for snippets of information, I'm a bit torn on some crutial and main events that should be mentioned in the Theme News Files that I'm writing. I'm wondering if the community can possibly give me some points of interest from episodes 1-23... Things that are important, places, or events that shape the journey of Ed and Al.

I'm also considering what area to build on the IC Grid - I'm leaning towards Central. I didn't wish to build up too large of an area as that would isolate players. Does anyone remember where The Devil's Nest was located? - Would Central City be a good focal point? I tried looking online for a map of the territory, but outside finding a world map that shows different land regions [lacking the information where towns/cities are in relation to one another] I'm a bit stuck.

I appreciate any and all help and advise I may get. It's my hope to have the game in Beta-Testing mode up in two weeks, and then officially opened by Halloween. In addition, the game will support a set of OC Homunculi (predetermined - but that goes along with my own community)

Thank you again,
-Melissa

1 Veiws Discussed

Hello [13 Jul 2006|04:28pm]

roaming_fool
Hello, everyone. You have no idea how happy I was to find a community like this. I'm having so much fun with this series, but it seemed like wherever I went, the only thing people were discussing was the "relation shipper" issue.

I have a couple of questions for this community, since I'm very new to the fandom, and many of you seem to have been around the block a time or two. I'm actually in the middle of editing a story that I'm writing and wanted to make sure I had my facts straight.

First, was Ishbal a city or a nation? The impression I got from the anime was that it was a city that acted as a flash point for the entire Eastern Rebellion, but later you usually hear the characters referring to "Ishbal," not "The Rebellion." Not to mention that the Ishballans seemed to have a certain racial profile (brown skin and red eyes), that made them easy to distinguish, which would seem to apply to a nation of people.

Also, as a nitpick, is it "Ishballan" or "Ishbalite?" (I'm not even going to get into other possible spellings of "Ishbal." I'm writing it the way the official translators at Bones/Funimation/whoever put it out).

My second question is about the technology. Ametresis (I'm not too sure of my spelling here), as a parallel world would seem to follow our years of post-WWI, but instead of developing machinery, they've developed alchemy. Fair enough.

So, if they've developed alchemy instead of machinery, what type of war equipment do they have? My knowledge of weaponry is very limited, but it would also seem to be on par with late 1930's Europe...but I would have thought that something would have to give? That they're behind "Earth" as far as mechanics are concerned. Do they have shells? Have they started to use trench warfare or are they still lining up and running at each other? We know they haven't seen anything flying in the sky except birds, so the planes of the time that a lot of characters are named for would be out of the question, as would bombs and strafing runs. To put it more concisely, how are they fighting these wars?

And finally, we know that the State Alchemists were sent to the Eastern fronts, "during the last years of the war." The alchemists always seemed to me to be the equivalent of dropping a nuke in terms of widespread destruction, but they were obviously there for awhile before they got the amplifying red stones. How long were they there? We know those red stones pretty much ended the war, but what I want to know is how long they were there before that.

I could probably think of more questions, but I think this is enough for a first post.
11 Veiws Discussed

So Did Lt. Hawkeye Fall Into A Plot Hole? [08 Jul 2006|05:30pm]

redbrunja
After watching the series, I have two questions that I’d love to discuss, both relating to Riza.

It’s about her eye color and her actions in episode 51Collapse )
9 Veiws Discussed

Fangirliness ensues. [11 Jun 2006|10:20pm]

keishiko
[ mood | chipper ]

Hello everyone! I'm relatively new to the fandom and the obsession is still fresh... Anyhow, I scribbled a little essay the other day about FMA and someone suggested I share it here, and I always like a good discussion, so. ^__^

The essay is a bit wordy, but it's also relatively short. I apologize in advance for the rather random way it's written--it was really just stream-of-consciousness, and I just later on figured I might share it.

The first of two parts is a reflection on the various themes that FMA plays up. The second compares and contrasts the main characters in FMA with that of Rurouni Kenshin (Samurai X to some), Himura Kenshin.

Some spoilerage throughout the anime and what manga there is so far. Spoilers for the RK series (manga/anime) and OVAs.

Hope you enjoy it! Feedback and further discussion very much welcome!

How DO you make a fake LJ-cut anyway?? Oh well.

Discussed

My third Pondering... [09 May 2006|04:28pm]

elfinragdoll
[ mood | accomplished ]

Alright, boys and girls. Something else I've been pondering...

Hohenheim and Envy: the Genetics ProblemCollapse )

5 Veiws Discussed

Ed's a stripper! [01 May 2006|09:00pm]

elfinragdoll
[ mood | accomplished ]

Alright, here's something that always got me---Ed loses his right glove almost every episode and most of his trenchcoat about once every two or three, it seems. So where do they keep coming from?! I understand he could transmute them back together...but after all those times, you'd figure he'd lose too many pieces to do it, and the articles of clothing would get gradually smaller. We joke about how that's all that's in that suitcase they carry--endless white and red material. Thoughts?

4 Veiws Discussed

[20 Apr 2006|04:21pm]

elfinragdoll
[ mood | impressed ]

Hello, I was ecstatic to find this community, and am very sure that I'll enjoy it.

Something I've been pondering for a while:

Read more...Collapse )

10 Veiws Discussed

[26 Jan 2006|12:03am]

ekoko
So my friend and I were thinking recently...

Alchemy = Equivalent exchange, of course. Rearranging.

So, like... Theoretically, by rearranging the air particles...

Could you make alchemy-rainbows?

Because... We think about this a LOT, and...





... If this is too spammy I'll delete it. XD;
4 Veiws Discussed

The Philosopher's Stone: A Cureall? [09 Jan 2006|02:03pm]

ceasefire
So, a few late-night musings after I started planning out the last of my Havoc/Hawkeye fics for the 3-Part Series I've been writing...

Is the Philosopher's Stone really a cureall? (cut for manga spoilers up to the most recent chapters)Collapse )
4 Veiws Discussed

Two Discussions! Oh Joy! [03 Jan 2006|11:29pm]

aiyia
[ mood | curious ]

One About AlphonseCollapse )

---


And One about Winry. Some Manga Spoilers!Collapse )

That's all for today, folks. :3
5 Veiws Discussed

A theory... [23 Dec 2005|10:19am]

urplesquirrel
Cut for spoilers up to chapter 54Collapse )

Do you think my theory has any merit whatsoever, or am I just on drugs?
3 Veiws Discussed

Police [21 Dec 2005|10:00pm]

flareod
I was thinking about this a little while back and I was wondering if Amestris has a police force, and what kind of authority they'd have. I mean they don't seem very present at all really, unless they dress like the military. The military seem to investage everything ie. were investigating all the deaths, even the ones that weren't military related. Or since it's a military state would the the army just have all the authority. Next part's a spoiler for the end of the series:

Read more...Collapse )

Discuss within...
8 Veiws Discussed

Homunculi [20 Nov 2005|10:27pm]

flareod
Okay first of all I apologise for any and all incorrect spellings in the following post, and since it's about our good friends the Homunculi I delair a spoiler warning and place this under an LJ cut.

Read more...Collapse )
8 Veiws Discussed

Monetary Value of Gemstones in Amestris [16 Nov 2005|11:45am]

aguynamedgoo
We know that it is illegal to transmute gold in Amestris, however, what about gemstones? I was writing about jewelry in Amestris, and obviously we know that there is jewelry with gemstones on them (a woman was admiring some in Rush Valley), but are gemstones worth anything in Amestris, or are they just pretty rocks used to accent gold?

Here is what we know: gold, as I said, is illegal to transmute. From the looks of the manga, however, silver isn't (there was a Silver Alchemist who was killed by Scar). Also, when you think about gemstones and what they are made of, it's very possible to easily transmute them. (Hell, it's possible to recreate them in labs in our world.)

Diamonds are just carbon. Any alchemist with some coal or, hell, some burnt wood has enough carbon to transmute diamonds. Pearls? Just sand. Rubies? Corundum, which is aluminum oxide and a little iron, magnesium, or silica for color. All things that are easy to come by. Sapphires are basically the same thing, only with titanium instead of iron, magnesium, or silica to give them their color. Emeralds? Just beryl, or beryllium-aluminum silicate with a little chromium for color.

I believe that canon also provides some subtle evidence that gold is something that's rarer in the world where FMA takes place than in our world. The gold rush in Xenotime not withstanding, notice that the married characters have silver wedding rings instead of gold. Is it because that's just the custom there, is it because of something cultural in Japan, is it a stylistic decision of the animators, or is it because gold is so rare that few married couples can spare the expense?

This would also explain Rush Valley's high price tag on the piece of jewelry that was being admired: it's the gold that makes it valuable, not the shiny rocks that accent it. Rush Valley is also better known for its automail than it is its jewelry. It just happened to have a jewelry store and, apparently, a famous jeweler.

But then, all of this also implies I am buying into the same mistake that Suethors make: that alchemists are common, when canon tells us they really aren't. Some people may know some basic alchemy, not there's hardly dozens of alchemists per town, and even if there was, they'd have better things to do with their time and knowledge than transmute shiny rocks.

So what do you people think? Am I overthinking things? (I did kind of go in circles and refute my own theory...)
12 Veiws Discussed

[08 Nov 2005|06:02pm]

alli_chan
[ mood | curious ]

Since a lot of people in this community are also members of fma_spork, I figured most people would have seen the posts regarding l_envyxedward_l's fic, 'De Metalen Opera'. One of the things people seem to have a big problem with is the names of the Sins, 'Suicide' and 'Betrayal'.

Which got me thinking, what does everyone else find appropriate as names for the homunculi? Do they have to be cardinal sins? Are the original cardinal sins (eg Vainglory, Depression etc) acceptable? Do they even have to be sins at all?

(In case anyone else hasn't seen these posts, they can be found here and here; there was another one, but I can't seem to find it)

31 Veiws Discussed

Concerning the Royai relationship. [05 Nov 2005|01:43pm]

ceasefire
I have written an Essay on the subject of Royai lemons, and their relationship in general after reading one too many badfics.

I must warn you there are some mature themes in there but nothing to be too concerned about.

The Roy/Riza relationship: Location, Characterization, Consumation and Conception

Feel free to drop a comment!

X-Posted to fm_alchemist, fma_discussion and royai.
Discussed

Is The Anime Bad? [29 Oct 2005|04:11pm]

flareod
Here's something that's been annoying me for a long time. It's basically where people start paying out the anime for being "OOC", "Raping the Canon" and "Nothing like the manga/the way Arakawa wants it" etc. They then go to worship the manga and it's fantastic storyline. Now I must admit, the anime does have its fair share of flaws and plot holes, but overall I think it's a fantastic anime series.
My major problem is though, that alot of people start liking FMA because they like the series, rather than the manga, but as soon as they read the manga they start hating the series and saying it's bad. Now is it just me, or is this irrational? I mean, if you started liking the series via the anime, then obviously it's a good series isn't it? It may not be very good in comparison to the manga, but it's still a good series, is it not?

I suppose this is also a bit of a Manga vs Anime discussion as well. What do you think of this kind of thing?
11 Veiws Discussed

Amestris & co. [25 Oct 2005|03:35pm]

hola_meg_a_cola
Some time ago, I heard a rumor that Roy was part Xingese. The rumor has yet to be confirmed or denied but it got me thinking about Amestris/its surrounding countries and some theories...

Continue to the musings...Collapse )
8 Veiws Discussed

navigation
[ viewing | most recent entries ]
[ go | earlier ]